How to Scrap Bad Ideas!
- Thistle Corner
- Jan 16
- 2 min read
Updated: Jan 23
Sometimes, ideas feel too important to let go. They’re personal, maybe even therapeutic, and yet you know they’re dragging your story down. They don’t push the plot forward, deepen the characters, or add real value. As tough as it is, sometimes those ideas have to go— but scrapping them doesn’t have to be painful, and it doesn't have to mean losing them forever!
This is something I’ve wrestled with in my own writing, and over time, I’ve developed a few ways to make it easier.
1. Don't Just Scrap Bad Ideas... SAVE THEM!
Cutting material doesn’t mean it’s gone for good. I like to keep a journal or file of ideas, scenes or dialogues that don’t work right now; they might be perfect for a later project. When I need inspiration, I can go back to those scrapped ideas, and they can often spark something new.
2. Rework Instead of Remove
Sometimes, an idea just needs reshaping. A long, clunky scene might work better when fragmented and spread out. Instead of losing the moment entirely, consider if you could reduce it to its good parts and even maybe spread these out across your story.
3. Scrap Bad Ideas? Sounds Fun!
Don't see it as painful or shameful to scrap bad ideas! Once you start, there’s something satisfying about cutting what doesn’t work and polishing what does. Think of it as streamlining your story to make it the best it can be — another chance to showcase your writing talent can be found in the skilfulness of your editing!
4. Keep Your Readers in Mind
Imagine your ideal reader. Would they be as captivated by the idea as you are, or would something feel off? Thinking about your audience can help you let go of what isn’t working. Instead of being afraid of it, let the pressure of what your readers might think inspire you!
5. Don’t Be Too Precious
It’s hard to part with ideas you’ve worked so hard on, but remember: letting go of what isn’t working makes room for something better. Pride can hold you back, but if it makes your story stronger, more interesting, then you're only benefitting yourself if you scrap what's not working!
REMEMBER:
“To scrap bad ideas is a difficult but necessary part of writing.”
How do you decide what to cut? Share your thoughts in the comments, or let me know on social media! @25thistlecorner
Comments